HOME     ABOUT     ADVERTISE     DONATE     MEDIA     SUBSCRIBE     tips@bigheadDC.com
BIG HEADLINE NEWS, featuring AP reports

HOT HEADLINERS
Friday February 15th, 2008 2:32 PM by BHDC Staff  
Filed under: Journalism, Amy Argetsinger, Washington Post, David Vitter

From the City Paper:

Last July, Post gossip columnist Amy Argetsinger was making some calls on David Vitter, the Louisiana senator whose phone number had shown up in the phone records of the famous “D.C. Madam.” After the story bounced all over the country, a New Orleans madam spoke up with allegations that Vitter had been a client of her brothel.

Argetsinger was all over it, nailing an interview with the Southern madam and pushing it toward publication. But her editor, Steve Reiss, spiked the story on sourcing grounds, arguing that the Post account rested precariously on the word of the New Orleans madam. Says Argetsinger via e-mail: “Reiss was aware that everyone else was writing about her but said that we can’t use that as an excuse—in essence, that the Post had to take the higher moral ground.” Argetsinger rushed to find a replacement item.

The next day, the columnist set out to “revisit” the Vitter issue. She pumped “New Orleans madam” into Google and found that the first story to pop up came from the Post. Turns out that washingtonpost.com had piped into the Web site an AP version of the very same story that a Style editor had just killed.

Argetsinger wasn’t mad; she was encouraged. Now she had an argument for her editors: Hey, if we have the AP story on our site, why can’t we publish our own version? “I guess I was arguing, ‘look, the Post’s already tainted here,’” writes Argetsinger via e-mail. Not tainted enough: When the issue reached the desk of top editor Downie, he sided with Argetsinger’s editor.

“Two different companies and two different standards operating under the same rubric”—that’s how Argetsinger sums it up.

................................................................................................................................................................................................




 

E-mail this post:





e-mail this
facebook
del.icio.us
stumble

  1. 4 Comments to 'Post Gossip Was Prevented From Writing About Sen. David Vitter’s Madam'


  1. 1. thefrontpage said:


    Obviously, one was an AP story and the other would have been a Washington Post. There is a huge difference in running an AP story and a staff-written story, so that’s the difference here. Everyone should read The Reliable Source column–they do a great job. And the column should be praised for actually researching and documenting their items, as opposed to some others in the same business.

    posted February 18th, 2008 at 10:50 am | Quote

  1. 2. Insider said:


    Yeah, but Amy Argetsinger was soooooo pissed this happened.

    posted February 18th, 2008 at 10:52 am | Quote

  1. 3. Mike said:


    So the WaPo is full of hypocrites from the top down — this is news? Even funnier is the McCain people thinking an endorsement from Bush I is positive. The only way that failed administration looks good is compared to the far worse record of his fratboy son.

    posted February 18th, 2008 at 11:45 am | Quote

  1. 4. redcanada said:


    head boy pets yahoo boat vacant water house me microsoft england girl ibm

    posted June 22nd, 2008 at 11:36 pm | Quote

Post Your Comment:

Quicktags:                





................................................................................................................................................................................................







Syndication
Subscribe Subscribe to BHDC


Anonymous Tips

Recent Comments
Larry King Can't Pronounce the Word "Misogynistic"  (21)
Anti-Scott, ProtestVoter, Interested Bystander, Dave [...]

Joe Biden Chet Edwards It Is?!  (455)
James, Curioso, Chisholm, Curioso [...]

Tina Palin  (6)
Betty Sue, Tina Fey, typical white person, Tina Fey [...]

Sara Benincasa for President!  (77)
Curioso, Curioso, typical white person, Interested Bystander [...]

Huma Abedin - 'Volcanic' on Google - Who Is Behind?  (25)
tall_blonde, Nguepneng Raphael, Steph H, Skippy Handleman [...]

Tipsters Aching for a Blog War to Leak into Real Life  (16)
The Truth, Mary, EricaB is Stupid, Felicia [...]

Rielle Hunter (aka Lisa Druck), Contact Us  (27)
aoidhn, Betsy, ELAINE N. RAMEY, Bastard [...]

The McCain Sisters!  (38)
humanity first, Sandra, Helen, Sunny [...]

Sinclair Plans to Talk to Enquirer  (1097)
Curioso, jeanniejo, Chisholm, Interested Bystander [...]

Is This Racist?  (12)
noo123, xbjllb, XenonII, Wondering [...]

Cindy McCain: Bush Spread Rumors That John Fathered Black Child Out of Wedlock  (18)
Brenda Fox, , irmsi, aural margin [...]

Book: Obama Tried to Inject Heroin  (7)
EricBellar, , Ariane, Mike G [...]

Kucinich's Scandalously Bad Book Deal  (6)
bill clintonson, Nicky Fenton, Soup Boi, shannon sparks [...]

"DC Madam" Not Gagged on WSRadio.com  (1)
chevima

Lauren Bush Might Be a Hippie!  (5)
oksanako, Intawspasia, Love it!, Masked Blogger [...]

Rumors: Bill Clinton Cleaning House At Camp Hillary; James Carville Is a Candidate to Join Her Team  (2)
kathleen robinson, kathleen robinson

Matalin Swipes McCain's Bangladeshi Daughter?  (8)
shahed nazrul, shahed nazrul, shahed nazrul, Al [...]

Tucker Carlson: the Big Head DC Interview  (15)
bonnie, John Doh, Jim, Kilbot [...]


BHDC Files