Filed under: Journalism, Scandals, CNN, Washington Post, Howard Kurtz, Gawker
Maggie Shnayerson, a new Gawker associate editor, is alleging that the Washington Post’s media critic Howard Kurtz plagiarized portions of his new book, “Reality Show: Inside the Last Great Television News War.” In her analysis, she centers on an excerpt from the book that appeared on the Drudge Report on Sunday:
That excerpt recounts a discussion between Dan Rather and ‘60 Minutes’ executive producer Josh Howard that took place on the eve of the airing of the controversial piece that would end Rather’s career at the network. Kurtz’s story was treated as big news—but the substance, and some of the language as well, was no different from New York Press editor-in-chief David Blum’s 2004 book, “Tick… Tick… Tick..: The Long Life and Turbulent Times of 60 Minutes.”
The meat of the Drudge-worthy news from Kurtz was that Rather said he’d take his items to the Times. But Blum had published that in his book:
Kurtz writes, “The night before the story was tentatively scheduled to air, Rather was sitting at the anchor desk, with less than half an hour before the start of the Evening News.”
…Rather’s discussion with Howard was over prime-time promotion of the piece. Both Kurtz and Blum write that Howard told Rather the piece might not even run, considering it hadn’t been vetted by CBS lawyers, nor had a call been made to the White House for contact.
Kurtz writes, “That was not the answer Rather wanted to hear.”
Blum’s own follow-up sentence, written three years previous? “This wasn’t what Rather wanted to hear.”
Shnayerson’s charges, no doubt, are weighty, although, as she notes, she did once work for Blum at The Village Voice.
Still, Kurtz, who also hosts CNN’s Reliable Sources, has been compelled to defend his work:
“I’m told the Rather incident was in the paperback of Blum’s book, which I never saw,” Kurtz told Big Head DC via e-mail this morning. “Good for him for getting it first, but if anyone picked it up it escaped my notice. I got the information firsthand from Josh Howard. I’m a fanatic about giving credit, which is why my book is filled with footnotes.”
[…] Money Honey Mad At Chris Matthews | Jenna Bush Hears Dead People | Mitt Romney Runs From Wheel Chair Questioner | Bob Novak Wants to Slap Sen. Craig | More To Come Re: Wonkette Editor’s Affair With Married Woman | Harold Ford, Jr.’s Blonde Ambition | Would You Rather Get Drunk With Jenna Bush or Prince Harry? | GOP Logo Gets an Extreme Gay Makeover | Congresswoman Yells, ‘Don’t Play Me’; Yanks Reporter’s Arm David Blum Is Tick, Tick, Ticked At Howie Kurtz Wednesday October 10th, 2007 10:48 AM by BHDC Staff Filed under: Scandals, CNN, Washington Post, Howard Kurtz While WaPo’s Howard Kurtz told us this morning that he didn’t copy any excerpts from David Blum’s 2005 book, “Tick… Tick… Tick..: The Long Life and Turbulent Times of 60 Minutes,” for his new book, “Reality Show,” Blum still, apparently, needs a bit more convincing. “It doesn’t seem like a scoop to me,” Blum told the New York Observer, after faxing them a copy of his long ago published scoop. According to their media blog, he was quite “aggitated” by Kurtz’ re-hash. ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. email this | digg this | del.icio.us | stumble | reddit | permalink […]
[…] Earlier: Howie Kurtz Defends Self From Plagiarism Charges ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. email this | digg this | del.icio.us | stumble | reddit | permalink […]
[…] After all, in addition to interviewing enterprising media folks like Touby, Kurtz is still dealing with the backlash from reports that he recently passed off a colleague’s scoop as his own by neglecting to credit New York Press editor David Blum with a “scoop” that he “glanced” at—then reproduced without proper citation. All in all, a juicy story – and one that was, coincidentally, originated and perpetuated by those pesky media sites Kurtz has conceivably come to resent. […]
[…] After all, in addition to interviewing enterprising media folks like Touby, Kurtz is still dealing with the backlash from reports that he recently passed off a colleague’s scoop as his own by neglecting to credit New York Press editor David Blum with a “scoop” that he “glanced” at—then reproduced without proper citation. All in all, a juicy story – and one that was, coincidentally, originated and perpetuated by those pesky media sites Kurtz has conceivably come to resent. […]
[…] Critics | Rockettes Kick For Legless Soldiers | Download Your Own Scary Larry Craig Mask Howie Kurtz: I Exposed Jack Kelley & Jayson Blair Wednesday October 24th, 2007 12:48 PM by BHDC Staff Filed under: Journalism,Howard Kurtz, Gawker MarketWatch’s Jon Friedman thinks the WaPo media critic faced a “the Blum debacle”>bum rap” during the plagiarism scandal he recently faced: What struck me was the glee that some bloggers displayed when they ripped Kurtz and his book. […]
Post Your Comment:
WordPress database error: [Server shutdown in progress]
SELECT comment_post_ID, post_title FROM (wp_comments LEFT JOIN wp_posts ON (comment_post_ID = ID)) WHERE comment_approved = '1' AND wp_posts.post_status='publish' AND comment_type<>'pingback' AND comment_type<>'trackback' ORDER BY comment_date DESC;WordPress database error: [Lost connection to MySQL server during query]
SELECT cat_ID, cat_name, category_nicename, category_description, category_parent, category_count FROM wp_categories WHERE cat_ID > 0 AND cat_ID <> 34 ORDER BY cat_name ascLegal/Privacy