The guy with the finger in his ice cream wouldn’t return it, even though doctors say they might have been able to reattach it. He wanted to keep it as evidence, so he could sue the store. Experts say that there were many other ways to lawfully note that the finger had been in his ice cream, while still returning the finger. Public opinion is now turning against him, reports the AP. This has definitely been a bad year for people who find fingers in their food.